The increasing need for sustainable acid mine drainage (AMD) treatment has spurred much attention to strategic development of resource recovery. Along this line, we envisage that a coupled electrochemical system involving anodic Fe(II) oxidation and cathodic alkaline production will facilitate in situ synthesis of schwertmannite from AMD. Multiple physicochemical studies showed the successful formation of electrochemistry-induced schwert-mannite, with its surface structure and chemical composition closely related to the applied current. A low current (e.g., 50 mA) led to the formation of schwertmannite having a small specific surface area (SSA) of 122.8 m2 g-1 and containing small amounts of -OH groups (formula Fe8O8(OH)4.49(SO4)1.76), whereas a large current (e.g., 200 mA) led to schwertmannite high in SSA (169.5 m2 g-1) and amounts of -OH groups (formula Fe8O8(OH)5.16(SO4)1.42). Mechanistic studies revealed that the reactive oxygen species (ROS)-mediated pathway, rather than the direct oxidation pathway, plays a dominant role in accelerating Fe(II) oxidation, especially at high currents. The abundance of center dot OH in the bulk solution, along with the cathodic production of OH-, were the key to obtaining schwertmannite with desirable properties. It was also found to function as a powerful sorbent in removal of arsenic species from the aqueous phase.